Editing Talk:HMS Allegiance

From TemeraireWiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision Your text
Line 26: Line 26:
Does anyone know who did this map? And can they do a similar one for Temeraire's return trip overland? [[User:Andrew|Andrew]] 05:13, 9 January 2008 (PST)
Does anyone know who did this map? And can they do a similar one for Temeraire's return trip overland? [[User:Andrew|Andrew]] 05:13, 9 January 2008 (PST)
== Sketch of Allegiance ==
Can anybody do a sketch of the ''Allegiance''? I have some trouble picturing exactly what she looks like, and what the difference in scale is between, say, her and HMS ''Surprise''.--[[User:SarekOfVulcan|SarekOfVulcan]] 09:00, 22 January 2008 (PST)
== Regarding Issues with the route taken ==
I was reading through several notes about Temeraire on both Wikipedia and Tvtropes, and one complaint was that the route taken by the Allegiance isn't the fastest route to take (To get to the Cape Of Good Hope from Europe, it's quicker to sail to Brazil, and then follow the strong winds of the Clipper Route. This may sound like an error, unless one considers the amount of food that is eaten by the dragons on board the transports. For example, when the Allegiance sailed to Africa with Lily's formation, the reason they would have taken the shorter route would have been; 1, With the dragons requiring too much food than could be stored on the ship, continuous stops were required to reload, and 2. The winds of the clipper route are highly dangerous, and could sink the ship.
Any thoughts on this? It just occurs to me that this issue could soon spring up on one of the pages sooner or later, and we should address it and either explain it or (preferably not) mark it as a goof and move on.
:I don't recall offhand whether the book talked very much about making provisioning stops on the coast. It's true that before Temeraire's arrival, British aviators (and their dragons) don't seem to've considered fishing for tunnys etc. instead of an endless supply of cattle... but OTOH the huge dragondeck implies a huge volume of ship underneath it that could be used for storage, plus enough ballast room at the other end of the ship to counterweight the dragons. My big question is what keeps the dragondeck warm all the time? If they're burning coal, shouldn't there be more mention of smokestacks and some huge coal storage area? (If anything, resupplying fuel might be more of an issue, depending on whether heating the dragondeck is an absolute necessity or just makes the dragons less cranky.) --[[User:Wombat1138|Wombat1138]] 19:26, 14 August 2010 (PDT)
:Hmm. I don't know much about shipping, but I know the Cape of Good Horn is notoriously difficult to navigate. Perhaps a ship as large as the Allegiance would make it even more so? Plus there is the iceburg issue which a dragon wouldn't be font of, since it's clear they like warmer climates. I also wonder if the fact that Spain was an ally of the French at that time might've had something to do with it? --strangerface
== Mapping the HMS Allegiance ==
First of all, two cross-sections from Google images of the HMS Victory, as an example of what these ships looked like; http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2009/02/04/article-1136024-034D3BD7000005DC-70_468x276_popup.jpg
We already know that the Allegiance is about 400ft long (For comparison to another ship, that's nearly half the size of the RMS Titanic; 882 ft), has a draught (the distance between the waterline and the hull) of more than twenty feet (the Victory had a draught of 28ft) and (IIRC) that the Dragondeck goes from the forecastle to the first mast. Because mention is made about going up the stairs to the Dragondeck, we know that this area is one deck higher than the main deck, and the galley is directly under this, with the Aviator cabins the next deck below that. Because of this, the Poop Deck must be at least one deck higher than the Dragondeck, so the helmsmen can see over the dragons to steer the ship.
Now, in Throne of Jade, mention is made of two large cabins (these would have the large windows) at the back of the ship that get chopped up for Prince Yongxing, Liu Bao & Sun Kai. HMS Victory has three such rooms; two being large cabins, and the third being a wardroom (dining/recreation room), which we know the Allegiance has. Because only two such cabins are mentioned, we could assume that the Allegiance has the same number of decks as the Victory.
We should also assume that the masts are in different places on the Allegiance than on the Victory, else the Dragondeck would be ludicrously short, but insanely wide, and less likely to hold the weight of ten yellow reapers. Plus, the whole ship is supposed to look like a fan from above, so it could go back quite a bit. We also know that it has to be long enough for;
1. Temeraire to fit on one side, while Maximus and Lily fit on the other.
2. Maximus and Nitidus fit on one side, while the rest of their formation fits on the other.
Perhaps it looked something like this (as depicted with lousy ASCII skills)?
                |                  |                  |      D
  _____A______  |        B        |        C        |______________
--/ |______________________________O________________________________/--
  | |                                                              /
A: Poop Deck and Steering
B: Main Deck
C: Main Deck (Aviator's Area)
D: Dragondeck
E: Captain's Cabin (Liu Bao & Sun Kai)
F: Galley
G: Admiral's Cabin (Prince Yongxing)
H: Officers Cabins
I: Upper Gun Deck
J: Aviators Cabins
K: Wardroom
L: Main Gun Deck
M: Aviator Cabins?
N: Lower Gun Deck/Stores
O: Orlop Deck
P: Aft Hold
Q: Bilge Pump
R: Fore Hold
On the HMS Victory, Sailors ate and slept between the cannons on the Gun Decks, so it could be that the low-ranking aviators do a similar thing. Now, there could also have been an extra deck (so as not to force the ship lower under the weight of the dragons) and the Poop Deck could have been higher (or every other deck one level down, making it the same height as the Victory). The number of guns per deck is no issue, as the ship is long enough that it could easily carry 150 guns. Thoughts? [[User:Almaron|Almaron]] 01:30, 28 August 2010 (PDT)

Please note that all text contributions to the Temeraire Wiki may be used and edited by others.
If you don't want your writing to be edited mercilessly and redistributed at will, then don't submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource.

To edit this page, please answer the question that appears below (more info):

Cancel | Editing help (opens in new window)