Talk:Lung Tien Chuan

From TemeraireWiki
Revision as of 16:32, 7 January 2009 by Rose (talk | contribs) (DoB)

Jump to: navigation, search

I've taken out this paragraph as it seems redundent. The fondness and protectiveness of Dragons to their Captains or Companions is inherent in the relationship. While the example of the fight between Temeraire and Lien is interesting, I don't see how it adds anything here as a single sentence. The involvement of Chuan and Mianning in the fight is minimal.

"Fond og Mianning, and only wanting to protect him. He always tried to stay inbetween him and the fight, like in the dragon duel in China"


Is the Date of Birth, or hatching definitely the same? Just because the eggs were laid at the same time doesn't mean they have to hatch at the same time, does it? Indeed this could be part of the reason one egg was sent away. So that it wouldn't be clear which one was the "elder" twin. One would imagine that one egg was laid first, and one would hatch first possibly on the same day, possibly much later. (Biology isn't my strong point.) It might be an even bigger issue if the one laid first hatched second. Andrew 02:04, 7 January 2009 (PST)

I wouldn't swear to the exact day being the same, esp. as it seems that dragonets have some conscious choice as to when they decide to hatch. However, given that Temeraire's DOB is given only as month and year and given that the two eggs presumably have similar (if not identical) genesets and similar patterns of physiological development, I don't think Chuan's time of hatching could be much different?

In any case, Chuan's identification as the "elder" twin - presumably referring to laying order - does not seem to be in doubt even though the hatching order can not be known. Yong Xing refers to Temeraire's egg as "the second-born egg of Lung Tien Qian" (opening sequence of ToJ). When Laurence and Hammond first see Temeraire and Chuan together in Mianning's residence, Temeriare explains, "Chuan's egg was first, and then mine."

I'm thinking that the point in sending the second-laid egg away was not so much to protect the other egg's "elder" status as to protect the egg or the dragonet from "accidents" of the sort that Yong Xing was presumably planning for his brother in his plot to set Miankai on the throne. Rose 08:32, 7 January 2009 (PST)