Difference between revisions of "User talk:Whitearrow"

From TemeraireWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(dragon breeds)
Line 34: Line 34:
  
 
- [[User:Whitearrow|whitearrow]]
 
- [[User:Whitearrow|whitearrow]]
 +
 +
== dragon categories ==
  
 
Hi there.  I started out on the wiki with a plan of adding in more detail on the Chinese dragons from Throne of Jade.  I started with sorting by nationality, so that you could browse by nationality rather than just by first letter.  However, the category for Chinese Dragon Breeds was deleted without comment.  So, what's up?  It seemed to me that browsing by nationality adds to the information and functionality.  --[[User:Jhkim|Jhkim]] 23:06, 28 January 2007 (PST)
 
Hi there.  I started out on the wiki with a plan of adding in more detail on the Chinese dragons from Throne of Jade.  I started with sorting by nationality, so that you could browse by nationality rather than just by first letter.  However, the category for Chinese Dragon Breeds was deleted without comment.  So, what's up?  It seemed to me that browsing by nationality adds to the information and functionality.  --[[User:Jhkim|Jhkim]] 23:06, 28 January 2007 (PST)
 +
 +
Hi -- more detail on the Chinese dragons is definitely welcome!  With respect to the categories, I'd like to keep the categories to a manageable number while we concentrate on getting articles written -- I've seen wikis with things categorized down to an inch of their life, and frankly, it becomes more confusing than helpful.  The current category structure is something I drew out on paper, with the goal in mind of being useful but simple, and not so overspecific that we end up with tons of categories and subcategories that only have 3-5 articles each. 
 +
 +
Secondarily, although we may eventually want to categorize the dragon breeds by some kind of geographical grouping, I'm not sure nationality is necessarily the best route to go.  It has more than one meaning -- is it the nation the dragon is loyal to, or where that particular breed was first discovered or bred?  If it's the second (which I think would be more useful) then "nationality" can be kind of misleading (it's been a bit problematic in some cases with "National Loyalty" in the dragon profile) and I think we need another name and way to make it clear. 
 +
 +
So I think it's something that needs a bit more thought before we plow ahead, and it's not something we need to decide right away.  Plus, once we decide to go ahead, someone needs to take the responsibility for putting all the dragons into their proper subcategories -- which is about 60 pages that will need updating.  At the moment, I'd rather that kind of time be spent on writing new articles -- we have red links that need help all over the place. :)
 +
 +
I'm sorry I didn't explain more thoroughly, that was my bad, and I apologize!  - [[User:Whitearrow|whitearrow]] 09:39, 29 January 2007 (PST)

Revision as of 17:39, 29 January 2007

Need me?

Leave me a note! Click the plus sign above.

Hey!

I saw that you've started this over on livejournal, and in your getting started that you might want a CSS/HTML editor and/or an artist. I've not edited Wiki sites before but I'm pretty fluent in buth CSS and HTML (anything I don't know, I'm willing to learn!), Photo-shop savvy and I'm looking for projects at the moment. And of course, I love Temeraire, so I'd be pretty excited to help out.

I'm off to poke around the place now and see how this thing works. It looks pretty nifty already!

Li

Hi, Li!

Glad to have you here!

I'd love to see something for the front page that looked a little nicer than what we have now, while communicating the same basic content.

If you'd like to play around with it, just start a page called front_test or something, and experiment to your heart's content!

A wiki you might want to look at is the Battlestar Galactica one, here: http://en.battlestarwiki.org/wiki/Main_Page

Let me know if you have any questions!

-whitearrow

heeee!

I can try to make one article a week expanded. Just tell me an article to expand, and i'll happily research it a bunch and add to it. feel free to contact me at msleppy@gmail.com


Hi -- I don't really have a priority list or anything as far as expansion goes, so just pick an article that seems of interest to you! I appreciate the help!

- whitearrow

dragon categories

Hi there. I started out on the wiki with a plan of adding in more detail on the Chinese dragons from Throne of Jade. I started with sorting by nationality, so that you could browse by nationality rather than just by first letter. However, the category for Chinese Dragon Breeds was deleted without comment. So, what's up? It seemed to me that browsing by nationality adds to the information and functionality. --Jhkim 23:06, 28 January 2007 (PST)

Hi -- more detail on the Chinese dragons is definitely welcome! With respect to the categories, I'd like to keep the categories to a manageable number while we concentrate on getting articles written -- I've seen wikis with things categorized down to an inch of their life, and frankly, it becomes more confusing than helpful. The current category structure is something I drew out on paper, with the goal in mind of being useful but simple, and not so overspecific that we end up with tons of categories and subcategories that only have 3-5 articles each.

Secondarily, although we may eventually want to categorize the dragon breeds by some kind of geographical grouping, I'm not sure nationality is necessarily the best route to go. It has more than one meaning -- is it the nation the dragon is loyal to, or where that particular breed was first discovered or bred? If it's the second (which I think would be more useful) then "nationality" can be kind of misleading (it's been a bit problematic in some cases with "National Loyalty" in the dragon profile) and I think we need another name and way to make it clear.

So I think it's something that needs a bit more thought before we plow ahead, and it's not something we need to decide right away. Plus, once we decide to go ahead, someone needs to take the responsibility for putting all the dragons into their proper subcategories -- which is about 60 pages that will need updating. At the moment, I'd rather that kind of time be spent on writing new articles -- we have red links that need help all over the place. :)

I'm sorry I didn't explain more thoroughly, that was my bad, and I apologize! - whitearrow 09:39, 29 January 2007 (PST)